Winning Brand Preference: What Established And Challenger Brands Need To Get Right
Brand leadership is a powerful advantage. Years of investment in reputation, innovation and consumer trust can make established brands the natural first choice for shoppers.
But market positions are never guaranteed. Consider the once dominant mobile phone leader Nokia. But also consider that every established brand was once a challenger.
Across categories, challenger brands are finding new ways to compete, whether through innovation, distinctive positioning, competitive pricing or a sharper understanding of changing consumer needs.
At the same time, consumers have more information and more choice at their fingertips. Digital comparison tools and AI-powered recommendations are making it easier to explore alternatives (as this article explores), potentially bringing lesser-known brands into consideration alongside familiar market leaders.
For established brands, the opportunity is to build on their existing strengths while continuing to demonstrate their relevance and value. For challengers, it's about converting newfound interest into sustainable growth.
The challenge for both is the same: how do you turn a competitive proposition into genuine consumer preference?
A strong brand is an advantage, not a guarantee
Established brands benefit from familiarity, proven performance and consumer confidence. These are significant competitive strengths, particularly in categories where shoppers are making considered purchases.
But consumers are increasingly able to compare competing propositions, weighing up features, performance, price and long-term value.
Consider the hair styling market. Established premium brands have built strong reputations through innovation, product performance and consumer trust. Yet newer competitors are giving shoppers more options, combining innovative features, different price points and compelling product propositions.
The emergence of alternatives doesn't diminish the value of established brands. Instead, it raises the importance of clearly communicating what makes each product worth choosing, whether that's superior performance, versatility, ease of use or long-term value.
The lesson isn't that brand loyalty is disappearing. It's that brands have to keep giving consumers compelling reasons to choose them.
For market leaders, that means continually reinforcing what makes their products worth buying. For emerging brands, it means demonstrating that an unfamiliar name can offer a credible, desirable alternative.
Differentiation creates interest. Execution builds momentum.
For challenger brands, a competitive price or distinctive proposition can provide an important entry point. But neither guarantees success.
A brand may have an innovative product, attractive pricing and a compelling marketing campaign, yet still struggle to convert interest into sales if shoppers can't easily find, understand or experience it.
This is where retail execution becomes a competitive advantage.
Take personal care brand Wild (acquired by Unilever), which challenged traditional deodorant formats with its refillable proposition. Alongside its distinctive product offering, the brand invested in physical retail visibility to communicate not just its sustainability credentials, but how the product works, why it's worth trying and what value it offers compared with familiar alternatives.
It's a useful illustration of how a differentiated proposition can be supported at the point of purchase. Clear presentation and accessible product information help shoppers understand an unfamiliar format and what makes it worth considering.
The same principle applies to consumer electronic categories, where consumers may be comparing products with different technologies, attachments and price points. Demonstrations and knowledgeable advice and signposting can help make those differences tangible, giving shoppers greater confidence in their decision.
Differentiation may give consumers a reason to look. The retail experience can give them a reason to buy.
Defending preference is as important as building it
While challenger brands focus on gaining attention and credibility, established brands face a different commercial challenge: maintaining preference when shoppers have more alternatives to consider.
Brand reputation and loyalty provide a strong foundation, but they still need to be supported by effective execution.
A premium product, for example, may offer superior performance, durability, functionality or after-sales support. Yet if those advantages aren't clearly communicated, shoppers may struggle to understand why they should pay more. Consider Gillette and challenger Harry’s who captured 14% of razor category sales value at US retailer Target within its first six months and now has 25% of the total market.
Effective merchandising, engaging demonstrations and knowledgeable brand representatives can help bring those differences to life.
For established brands, this is an opportunity to reinforce the value behind their reputation, support premium positioning and strengthen consumer confidence.
For challenger brands, the same activities can help establish credibility and overcome the hesitation associated with trying something unfamiliar.
Different starting points, but a shared need to make the brand proposition clear, tangible and relevant.
The importance of winning at the point of purchase
Availability and distribution remain essential, but being stocked is only part of the equation.
How a brand appears and performs in the retail environment can influence whether shoppers notice it, understand its benefits and ultimately choose it.
That means focusing on several connected priorities:
- Visibility: Ensuring products are easy to find, well presented and prominent in relevant retail environments.
- Availability: Maintaining stock and reducing missed sales opportunities.
- Product experience: Giving shoppers opportunities to see, try and understand what makes a product different.
- Knowledgeable people: Equipping retail teams and brand representatives to explain benefits, answer questions and build confidence.
- Consistent execution: Ensuring the brand proposition is delivered effectively across stores, channels and customer touchpoints.
For emerging brands, these elements can accelerate the journey from awareness to trial and purchase.
For established brands, they help protect preference, reinforce value and maximise the return on brand investment.
Importantly, retail execution isn't simply about influencing an individual transaction. Consistent, positive product experiences can also strengthen brand perceptions and encourage repeat purchase.
The brands that keep earning their place
The competitive landscape will continue to evolve as consumers discover new products, compare more alternatives and reassess what represents value.
For challenger brands, the opportunity to compete with established players is significant. But sustainable growth requires more than being different or less expensive. It demands consistent availability, strong execution and the ability to build consumer confidence.
For established brands, continued success means making the most of existing strengths while ensuring their products remain visible, relevant and compelling in an increasingly competitive market.
Ultimately, brand leadership and challenger growth aren't driven by positioning alone.
They're built by consistently giving shoppers a reason to notice, a reason to believe and a reason to choose.